Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nakayama's avatar

While I agree in general, I think normalization of poverty is inevitable even without any intention to keep it that way. The simple facts are food production is limited by soil depletion; fertilizers require large amounts of raw materials and energy to produce; reasonable residential areas close to jobs are all taken, and rivers no longer have enough water to flow to the sea. If you allow free enterprises, even with strong-arm regulations behind them, it would be extremely difficult to change these conditions by traditional means commonly used in the West. Chairman Mao achieved that by indirectly killing many people by policies. Conflicts cannot be resolved when there is resource shortage. Yes, some supreme arbitrator can force people to share, but inevitably the arbitrator becomes the first among the equals, as the EU Commissioner has demonstrated.

Please aim for more quantitative analysis in proposing solutions. Quite often, the controversies start because we don't have common definitions. And proper definitions really require trackable quantitative measurements, from global warming to wealth inequality. We need numbers to pinpoint the problems and numbers to justify solutions.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts